A Judge's Call for a Visa Fix After a Student's Wrongful Deportation
In a surprising turn of events, a federal judge in Boston has suggested a creative fix for a young student's deportation mix-up.
The Incident
The judge proposed that the U.S. government issue a student visa to Any Lucia Lopez Belloza, a 19-year-old college student who was mistakenly sent to Honduras. This happened after she was arrested at Boston's airport while trying to visit her family for Thanksgiving.
Background
Lopez Belloza, who came to the U.S. from Honduras at the age of 8, was detained based on a removal order she claims she was unaware of. Her lawyer quickly filed a lawsuit challenging her detention.
Legal Proceedings
- A federal judge in Massachusetts issued an order on November 21, preventing her deportation or transfer out of Massachusetts for 72 hours.
- However, by that time, Lopez Belloza had already been flown to Texas, potentially removing the court's jurisdiction.
- She was then sent to Honduras on November 22.
Government's Response
The government acknowledged that a court order was violated, blaming it on a "mistake" by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer. The officer thought the order no longer applied and failed to properly flag it. The government apologized but argued that no one should be held in contempt.
Judge's Suggestion
The judge, Richard Stearns, commended the government for acknowledging the mistake but emphasized the importance of finding a solution. He suggested that the State Department issue Lopez Belloza a student visa, allowing her to finish her studies. The judge acknowledged that a mistake was made and that Lopez Belloza is a sympathetic figure who deserves a solution.
Legal Arguments
Lopez Belloza's lawyer urged the judge to order the government to facilitate her return and hold officials in contempt. The judge did not immediately rule but floated the idea of a student visa as a practical solution.
Case Highlights
The case highlights the complexities and potential pitfalls of immigration enforcement, especially under a hardline immigration agenda.
