crimeneutral

A Teacher's Fall from Grace in Upstate New York

Johnstown, USASaturday, December 13, 2025
Advertisement

In a small town in Upstate New York, a trusted educator's life took a dramatic turn. Scott Jeffers, a 42-year-old special education teacher and coach, found himself on the wrong side of the law. He was taken into custody after being accused of sending inappropriate messages to a student under 17.

Details of the Allegations

  • Messages exchanged through social media, texts, calls, and in person.
  • Sexual in nature, touching on topics like drug use and physical violence.

Jeffers' Roles and Access

  • Worked at Johnstown Junior/Senior High School.
  • Coached soccer and track, giving him extra access to the student involved.
  • School superintendent reported the allegations on October 17, leading to an investigation.
  • Arrested and released on his own recognizance after a court appearance.

Police Investigation

  • Looking for other possible victims.
  • Urging anyone with information to come forward.

Impact on the Community

  • Shaken the small community of about 8,700 people.
  • Jeffers was also a member of the Johnstown City Common Council.
  • Considered running for mayor.
  • Follows another recent arrest of a city official, former Treasurer Thomas Herr, who was charged with official misconduct and other crimes.

About Johnstown

  • Known for its historic sites and proximity to larger cities like Syracuse and Saratoga Springs.
  • Grappling with the fallout from these arrests, leaving many questioning the integrity of their local leaders.

Actions