In Louisiana, a heated discussion is happening.  Some folks want to stop balloon releases.  They think it is bad for the environment.  Others say it is a way to honor loved ones.  They think it is a way to cope with loss.  The debate is about House Bill 581.  It wants to make balloon releases illegal.  It would fine people who let balloons go.  The first time, it would be 150 dollars.  The second time, it would be 250 dollars.  After that, it would be 500 dollars each time.  The bill is up for a final vote soon.  If it passes, it will go to the Senate.

The idea behind the bill is to reduce litter.  Balloons can get stuck in power lines.  This can cause power outages.  They can also hurt animals.  Cows might eat them and get sick.  They can end up in rivers and oceans.  This hurts fish and other sea creatures.  The person who proposed the bill, Representative John Illg, thinks this is a big problem.  He wants to stop it.  He said, "You don't realize the damage you're doing.  Would you be okay with people littering to memorialize something? "

The problem is, balloon releases are a big deal for some families.  They use them to remember loved ones who have passed away.  Cathy Toliver lost her grandson to gun violence.  She releases balloons in his memory.  She thinks it helps her connect with him.  She said, "We know they're no longer here, but when we release those balloons, it's like we're sending them up to Heaven. "  She thinks the bill is wrong.  She said, "If you pass this bill and say no more balloon releases, you are becoming a dictator.  You do not dictate to people how they can grieve. "

This is a tough situation.  On one hand, we want to protect the environment.  On the other hand, we want to respect people's ways of coping with loss.  It is a balance.  We need to find a way to honor both.  Maybe there are other ways to remember loved ones that are not harmful.  Maybe we can find a middle ground.  It is important to think about this carefully.  We need to consider all sides.  We need to find a solution that works for everyone.

Balloons: Tradition or Trash?

Actions