Buffy’s New Show Fizzles: One Executive Says It All

The buzz around a new Buffy series fizzled out quickly, leaving both fans and the cast stunned.
Sarah Michelle Gellar took to Instagram and a recent interview to explain that the decision came from a single person at Hulu.

She was taken aback when she received the call, especially as her film “Ready or Not 2” premiered at SXSW and a director friend was heading to the Oscars.
Gellar said that timing hurt both her and the audience, who had been eager for a fresh take on the Slayer.

In contrast to Gellar’s bluntness, director Chloé Zhao kept her comments vague, hinting that the cancellation was “unavoidable.”

Gellar highlighted a key executive who admitted he never watched the original series, making it hard to respect a show that meant so much to fans.
She didn’t name the executive, but reports point to Disney Television Group President Craig Erwich as the likely decision‑maker.

The pilot script had been rewritten to be more mature and include Gellar’s character—something many thought would secure approval.
However, the new version was reportedly too expensive for Hulu’s budget, and the network doubted it would meet expectations set by the beloved original.

Erwich allegedly called off the project late Friday, ending the revival’s chances.
Gellar says the story of Buffy lives on, and fans still deserve a quality show. She hopes someone will revive the franchise with respect for its legacy and the viewers who love it.