sportsneutral

Cody Bellinger Stays with Yankees: A Smart Move or a Risky Bet?

New York, USAThursday, January 22, 2026
Advertisement

The Yankees have made a significant move by re-signing Cody Bellinger. This deal is not just about keeping a good player; it's about strategy and power plays in the world of baseball negotiations.

A Versatile Asset

Bellinger is a versatile player. He can:

  • Play multiple positions
  • Hit home runs
  • Be a positive influence in the clubhouse

His uppercut swing is perfect for Yankee Stadium's short right-field porch, making him a valuable asset for the team.

The Deal

The Yankees offered Bellinger a:

  • Five-year, $162.5 million deal
  • $20 million signing bonus
  • Options to leave after the second or third seasons
  • Delay of options in case of a work stoppage in 2027

Negotiation Dynamics

Bellinger's agent, Scott Boras, initially wanted:

  • A seven-year deal
  • $37 million per year

However, the Yankees stood firm on their offer, knowing Bellinger's value but unwilling to overpay.

The Yankees' Confidence

The Yankees' current season win total is set at 92.5 games, showing confidence in their team, especially with Bellinger on board. Without him, the team would have faced a significant loss in offensive power.

Boras' Tactics

Boras had claimed that eight teams were interested in Bellinger. However, this seems to have been more of a negotiating tactic than reality. The Yankees used this to their advantage, showing they were the only serious contenders.

Learning from the Past

The Yankees' management was determined not to make the same mistake they did with Juan Soto. They had offered Soto a massive contract, but the Mets outbid them. This time, they stuck to their initial offer, showing a new level of discipline.

Factors in the Negotiations

Bellinger's age and recent performance were factors in the negotiations. He is not the superstar he once was, but he is still a valuable player. The Yankees' offer reflected this reality.

The Final Deal

In the end, Bellinger had no better options. The Mets acquired another outfielder, and the Blue Jays showed only mild interest. The Yankees increased their final offer slightly, showing good faith and securing Bellinger's return.

The Big Picture

This deal shows the Yankees' commitment to building a strong team. It also highlights the power dynamics in baseball negotiations. The Yankees came out on top, but only time will tell if this was the right move.

Actions