Does Religion Really Hurt Women's Health?

Religion and women's health have been topics of debate. Some argue that certain religious practices harm women. But is this claim backed by solid evidence? Let's dive in.

The Debate

A recent discussion highlighted concerns about how women are treated in religious settings. It suggested that religions not ordaining women might negatively impact women's health. However, this idea isn't strongly supported by research.

The Evidence

The argument relies heavily on one study. This study found that women in sexist congregations (where women can't hold top leadership roles) don't have worse health than women who don't attend religious services at all. So, it doesn't prove that these institutions harm women's health.

Broader Implications

Moreover, the broader claim that only religions ordaining women offer health benefits is debatable. Research on religion and health is vast. The Oxford Handbook of Religion and Health reviews thousands of studies. It shows that religious involvement generally leads to better mental, physical, and social well-being.

Health Outcomes

Looking at health outcomes by religious tradition and attendance, a clear pattern emerges. Higher religious attendance is linked to better health. This applies to religions that ordain women and those that don't. Even among atheists, higher religious participation is associated with better health.

Conclusion

It's important to discuss gender and religion. Practices that undermine anyone's dignity should be examined. However, the larger body of research doesn't support sweeping claims of harm. In fact, religious women often enjoy better mental and physical health, live longer, and have better social and relational health.

We should explore ways to keep women meaningfully connected to their faith. While overall trends are positive, individual experiences of harm must be addressed.