Faith Leaders React to Bishop's Call for Courage in the Face of ICE

A bishop's recent advice has ignited a heated discussion among clergy.

Controversial Advice

Bishop Rob Hirschfeld of New Hampshire advised clergy to prepare their wills, suggesting they might need to physically protect vulnerable individuals from ICE actions. This came after a vigil for Renee Macklin Good, who was shot by an ICE agent.

Support and Relief

Hirschfeld's words spread quickly online. Some clergy, like Reverend Jason Wells, felt relieved and validated. Wells often prays outside ICE offices and has seen the risks involved. He believes the bishop's message resonated with many who share the same anxiety.

Reverend Betsy Hess agreed, stating that clergy should be more active. However, she admitted uncertainty about the level of risk she's willing to take. The idea of facing arrest or even being shot has made many clergy reconsider their involvement.

Dissenting Opinions

Not everyone agreed with Hirschfeld. Reverend Tom Gartin found the message inflammatory. He believes the focus should be on peacemaking and de-escalation, not physical resistance. Gartin also expressed concern for his family and congregation, stating he didn't sign up to be a martyr.

Clarification and Context

Hirschfeld clarified that he wasn't advocating for violence or seeking trouble. He simply wants clergy to be prepared and live without the fear of death. He cited the example of Jonathan Daniels, a seminary student who was shot while protecting a Black teenager during the civil rights movement.

Government Response

The White House and DHS responded critically. They maintained that the ICE agent acted in self-defense and that interfering with federal law enforcement is a crime. DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin called the bishop's comments absurd, suggesting he should support ICE agents instead.

Final Stance

Hirschfeld expressed compassion for ICE agents, emphasizing the Christian responsibility to love all, even enemies. He acknowledged the complex situation but stood by his message.