Jaxson Dart: The Unfair Hype and Reality

Jaxson Dart, the New York Giants' rookie quarterback, has faced unfair criticism lately. Critics argue he's not improving and that the Giants made a mistake by letting Brian Daboll go. Some even suggest trading him for another quarterback like Fernando Mendoza. But let's analyze this carefully.

Dart's Stats and Potential

• Dart's stats this season are better than Cam Ward's, the number one pick.
• Many experts agree he has potential and deserves a fair chance.
• Todd McShay from The Ringer thought Dart was a perfect fit for Daboll's system.
• The Giants traded back into the first round to select Dart, as McShay predicted.

Dart's Performance Under Daboll

• Before Daboll was fired, Dart showed poise, mobility, and good decision-making.
• For a few weeks in October, it looked like the Giants had made a great draft pick.
• Next season will be crucial to see how Dart performs under a new coaching staff.

Expert Opinions on Dart

• Art Stapleton from the Bergen Record argues that the criticism is unfair.
• The problem is not Dart's performance but the lack of support from the Giants' players and coaches.
• If Dart were in the Class of 2026, he would be considered the top quarterback by many talent evaluators.

Giants' Offseason Decisions

• Jermaine Eluemunor, the veteran right tackle, has had two excellent seasons and deserves a nice payday.
• Marcus Mbow, the rookie offensive tackle, will start at left tackle in place of the injured Andrew Thomas in the next two games.
• If Mbow plays well, the Giants might spend money on other needs instead.

Joe Schoen's Future

• Joe Schoen, the Giants' general manager, has an uncertain future.
• The team's record over the past three seasons has been terrible.
• However, ownership has a solid relationship with Schoen and does not want to let him go unless necessary.

Giants and Raiders' Struggles

• Both the Giants and Raiders are struggling this season.
• Many starters will not play in their upcoming game.
• Some might call this tanking, but it's more likely appropriate caution with injured players.

Chances of the Number One Pick in 2026

• The Giants have a 37.6% chance at the number one pick.
• 73% chance with a loss.
• 6% chance with a win.
• The Raiders have a 36.2% chance at the number one pick.
• 69% chance with a loss.
• Less than 1% chance with a win.