Judge’s Gift Sparks New Trial Fight

After sentencing, the judge handed prosecutors a card and bracelet meant for the victim.

• The defense claims this off‑record gesture shows bias.
• They seek a new trial, while prosecutors request only a new sentencing judge.

Case Background

• The couple’s case began with a six‑day jury trial in September.
• Prosecutors alleged the victim was abused while trafficked from February to May 2022.

Off‑Record Gift Incident

• During sentencing, a court staffer gave the prosecutor an envelope containing a bracelet and seashells.
• The card read:
  “Every important journey in life starts with the 1st step … I wish you much joy.”
• The prosecutor opened it after the hearing, kept the gifts, and later informed the defense via email.

Legal Proceedings

• The defense filed a motion for a new trial on February 19.
• Judge Guzman recused herself the following day; a Boston judge was appointed.
• Prosecutors argue the defense has not met the legal standard for a new trial, asserting that the judge’s comments were reasonable and aimed at helping the absent victim.
• Defense lawyers contend the judge treated them unfairly, denied questions about the victim’s state, and gave an off‑record gift, undermining court neutrality.

Expert Opinion

• Experts say the gift appeared inappropriate, but it is unclear whether it will result in a new trial.
• The judge’s actions raise serious questions about impartiality.