New York prosecutors are facing an uphill battle in trying to charge Luigi Mangione with first-degree murder. The 26-year-old is accused of shooting and killing UnitedHealthCare CEO Brian Thompson on December 4. The indictment includes multiple counts, including first- and second-degree murder, weapon charges, and forgery. However, some legal experts argue that the terrorism charge might be a stretch.

Murder in the first degree is a rare charge in New York, reserved for specific situations like when the victim is a judge or police officer, or if the murder is a paid hit. Prosecutors claim that Mangione intended to incite terror by attacking a powerful CEO in a bustling city area. They point to widespread praise for Mangione on social media and heightened security concerns among corporate executives as evidence of this intent.

But not all experts agree. Stacy Schneider, a criminal defense attorney, believes the prosecution may struggle to prove the terrorism aspect. She suggests that the murder could be seen as more personal rather than a public terroristic act. Schneider also notes that the public outcry against the health insurance industry doesn't negate the fact that the act was unpredictable and unintended.

The goal of including the terrorism charge could be strategic. Former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth suggests that it might be a move to pressure Mangione into pleading guilty to a lesser charge. The jail time for first-degree murder is life without parole, which could provoke public backlash given the current social climate.

Rebecca Weiner, deputy commissioner of the NYPD's Intelligence & Counterterrorism unit, maintains that the killing was intended to evoke terror, citing real-world threats and online rhetoric as evidence. The issue at hand is whether Mangione's actions genuinely met the criteria for first-degree murder under New York law.

Murder Charges Against UnitedHealth CEO Shooting Suspect: Too Much?

Actions