Texas School Ratings: What Families Need to Know

The Texas Education Agency (TEA) has finally made public the A‑F grades for all state schools, after a series of legal battles that delayed the 2023 and 2024 releases. These grades are meant to give parents a quick snapshot of how their local schools perform, but the process has been fraught with controversy. The A‑F system was introduced in 2017 to meet state accountability laws and relies heavily on standardized test results. Three main factors shape a school’s letter: student achievement, how much progress the school makes compared to its own past performance and similar schools, and whether the school is closing achievement gaps among different student groups. Seventy percent of the overall grade comes from either achievement or progress, while closing gaps accounts for thirty percent. A key change that sparked lawsuits involved the college, career and military readiness (CCMR) metric. In 2017 TEA set a threshold that if sixty percent of graduates were deemed CCMR ready, the school could earn an A. The state later raised this bar and removed credit for certain popular certifications, such as Google Analytics, which many districts had counted toward CCMR. Critics said the new rules were announced too quickly and without enough notice, leading to fears that schools could lose grades even if their students performed better.

The second round of legal action focused on the use of computer scoring for STAAR essay questions introduced in late 2023. After implementation, many high‑school students received zeroes on their written responses, prompting districts like Dallas ISD to request rescoring. The district argued that the automated system unfairly lowered school ratings and questioned its validity. TEA defended the technology as a reliable tool that matches human scorers in accuracy and efficiency. In July 2025, the 15th Court of Appeals ruled in favor of TEA, allowing the 2024 A‑F grades to be released. The court noted that while automated scoring systems are not perfect, they provide consistent results and do not invalidate the entire assessment. The decision emphasized that local courts should no longer block TEA’s accountability plans, and it highlighted the importance of transparency for parents and school boards. These events underline how changes in evaluation criteria and assessment technology can ripple through the education system, affecting public perception, school funding, and ultimately student outcomes. Parents are encouraged to look beyond the single letter and examine the underlying data to get a fuller picture of their school’s performance.

Actions