The Health Department's Shaky Science: A Closer Look
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is facing criticism over a recent report that challenges the validity of gender-affirming care. Released just weeks after a presidential directive, the report has drawn scrutiny due to its questionable methods and lack of transparency.
Key Claims and Controversies
Challenging Medical Consensus: The report asserts that gender-affirming care is not medicine but malpractice, contradicting the stance of major medical organizations. These groups affirm that gender-affirming care significantly improves the health of transgender youth.
Misrepresentation of Data: The report suggests that many young people are rushing into permanent changes, while ignoring the fact that the number of trans patients receiving gender-affirming surgery before 18 is very low. It also misrepresents the regret rate for gender-affirming care.
Ignoring Irreversible Changes: The report fails to acknowledge that allowing puberty to proceed is itself an irreversible change.
Backlash from Medical Organizations
The report has been condemned by prominent medical associations, including:
- The American Psychiatric Association
- The American Medical Association
- The American Academy of Pediatrics
These organizations argue that the report's claims lack scientific validity and could harm vulnerable young people and their families.
Broader Context of Distrust in Federal Health Agencies
The report's release coincides with growing skepticism toward federal health agencies, fueled by the spread of conspiracy theories and misinformation. It is crucial to rely on evidence-based conclusions, such as:
- Vaccines save lives.
- Tylenol does not cause autism.
- Wi-Fi is not mind control.
Call to Action
The HHS is urged to prioritize expanding access to healthcare rather than restricting it. This includes ensuring that transgender and intersex individuals receive the care they need.
