The Price of Pride: How Titles Almost Toppled a Nation

In 1789, the United States faced a peculiar debate. The question wasn't about laws or rights, but about what to call the president.

The Proposal

• John Adams, then vice president, led the charge for grand titles like:
• "His Elective Highness"
• "His Majesty"
• A committee even suggested: "His Highness the President of the United States and Protector of Their Liberties"

The Opposition

The Senate was divided. Some senators argued that titles of nobility went against the principles of the American republic.

• Key Points:
• All men are equal.
• Titles create unnecessary divisions.

The Outcome

• John Adams gave a long speech, criticizing those who opposed his ideas.
• House of Representatives decided to stick with the simple "The President of the United States."
• George Washington, the first president, preferred to be called "Mr. President."

The Aftermath

• Washington's Approach:
• True respect comes from actions, not titles.
• His humility and virtue spoke volumes about the dignity of the republic.

• Adams' Backlash:
• Opponents mocked him, calling him "His Rotundity."
• Had to repeatedly assure people of his commitment to the principles of 1776.

The Broader Implications

The debate over titles was more than just about words. It was about the values of the new nation.

• Adams' Insistence:

• Raised suspicions about his loyalty to republican principles.

• Washington's Example:
• Set an example of humility and simplicity.
• The nation chose to follow Washington's lead, valuing simplicity over pomp and circumstance.

The Continuing Debate

Today, the debate over titles and dignity continues.

• Arguments:
• Grandeur and luxury are necessary to show the nation's strength.

• True dignity lies in simplicity and humility.

• Quote:

• "The more simple we are, the more national dignity we shall acquire." — James Madison

• Question:
• How will history judge our choices?