politicsconservative

The Tiny Island at the Heart of a Big Dispute

Chagos ArchipelagoSaturday, January 24, 2026
Advertisement

In the vast Indian Ocean, a small island named Diego Garcia is causing a big stir.

The Military Base

  • Location: Part of the Chagos Archipelago
  • Tenancy: Leased by the United States from Britain since the 1970s
  • Lease Duration: Until at least 2036
  • Personnel: Around 2,500, mostly American
  • Role: Central to US operations in the region, including campaigns in Afghanistan and Iraq
  • Controversy: Linked to secret CIA facilities

Historical Context

  • Original Status: Part of Mauritius, a former British colony
  • Separation: 1965, by Britain
  • Expulsion: About 2,000 original residents were expelled to make way for the US base
  • Current Status: Many residents and descendants live in Mauritius, campaigning for the right to return

International Rulings and Resolutions

  • 2019 International Court of Justice Ruling: The separation of the Chagos Islands from Mauritius was unlawful
  • 2019 UN General Assembly Resolution: Called on Britain to withdraw its administration from the islands
  • Votes Against: Only six countries, including Britain, the United States, and Israel

Recent Developments

  • 2023 Agreement: Britain and Mauritius agreed to transfer sovereignty over all of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius
  • Terms: Britain would pay Mauritius $136 million a year for a 99-year lease of the military base on Diego Garcia
  • Purpose: To allow Britain and the United States to continue operating the base
  • US Opposition: President Donald Trump has recently opposed this agreement
  • Political Storm: Reignited in Britain, with some politicians criticizing the deal
  • Uncertainty: Whether Trump's objections will derail the agreement, given Labour's large majority in Parliament

The Chagossians' Perspective

  • Negotiations: Conducted without the involvement of the Chagossians themselves
  • Survey Findings: Most Chagossians favor remaining under British rule and oppose transferring sovereignty to Mauritius
  • Mauritius' Stance: Stressed that its sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago is clearly established under international law

Broader Implications

  • Clash of Worldviews: The dispute reflects a deeper clash of worldviews
  • Key Issues:
  • The future of international law
  • The rights of displaced people
  • The role of military bases in global politics

Actions