TI and Tiny's Supreme Court Battle: 'It's Not Over Yet'

Everyone thought it was a done deal—TI and Tiny Harris, the celebrity couple, had won a massive lawsuit against MGA Entertainment. It was all about trademarks: the company had made dolls that looked and sounded a lot like their girl group, OMG Girlz. The jury agreed, slapping MGA with a $71 million verdict. But here’s where it gets interesting. Judge James Selna looked at the case and said, "Hold on, not so fast. " He ruled that there wasn't enough proof that MGA copied the OMG Girlz designs on purpose. That’s a big deal because the law says companies need to knowingly infringe on trademarks to qualify for big penalties. So, Judge Selna chopped off $53 million from the award.

TI and Tiny are still getting money—a cool $17 million. But that's not the $71 million they were hoping for. When Tiny talked to People Magazine after the initial victory, she was thrilled: "We wanted to thank the jurors for seeing us through this. " TI, her husband, agreed, saying they were happy their story was believed. So, what’s the takeaway? Even when you win big, it’s not always a sure thing. Proof matters, and sometimes, that makes all the difference.

Actions