Weather Research in the Crosshairs: A Shift in Science Policy

The Trump administration is planning a significant overhaul in the world of weather and climate research. The National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) in Colorado could soon face a major shake-up.

Key Points

• Russ Vought, head of the Office of Management and Budget, announced the plan on X.
• The National Science Foundation is considering breaking up NCAR.
• Vought described NCAR as a "big source of climate alarmism."
• Important research, such as weather forecasting, will be moved to other institutions.

Broader Implications

This move is part of a larger effort by the Trump administration to limit what they perceive as taxpayer-funded advocacy.

• Critics argue that NCAR is a leading research hub established in 1960.
• Scientists worldwide rely on its resources.
• The administration believes NCAR has strayed from its original mission, focusing more on political advocacy.

Reactions

• Democrats and scientists are outraged, warning of negative impacts on research and public safety.
• Colorado Governor Jared Polis emphasized the importance of NCAR's data for disaster preparedness.
• Antonio Busalacchi, head of UCAR (which manages NCAR), stated that dismantling NCAR would hinder the nation's ability to handle severe weather and natural disasters.

Additional Changes

• Earlier this year, the administration proposed cuts to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's research arm.
• Critics warned these cuts would harm weather forecasting.
• The administration insists that vital NCAR functions will not be eliminated, but will be relocated.

The Debate

This sets the stage for a major debate:

• Who decides what counts as science?
• Who decides what counts as advocacy?