When Protests Meet Reality: A Look at the Cost of Overconfidence

In recent events, many are questioning the actions of law enforcement, particularly in immigration enforcement. The deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti have ignited debates about whether officers could have used less lethal methods. However, it's crucial to consider the broader context.

Protests: Performance or Political Change?

Protests have become a means of expression, but sometimes they evolve into performances rather than meaningful actions. This isn't a new phenomenon. In the 1960s, protests were often seen as a way to address personal issues rather than drive real political change. People would shout at police as if dealing with a parent figure, according to poet Robert Bly.

The Impact of Modern Praise Culture

Many today have grown up with excessive praise and little criticism, fostering a sense of entitlement and a lack of understanding of real-world consequences. Writer Alexandra Wolfe highlighted this in 2004, noting how TV shows like American Idol and The Apprentice exposed people to harsh truths about their talents and abilities.

The Fine Line Between Protest and Recklessness

There's a delicate balance between standing up for beliefs and acting recklessly. Good and Pretti seemed to embody a sense of invincibility as they confronted immigration enforcement officers. Their confident expressions before the tragic outcome reminded some of American Idol contestants who enter thinking they are the best, only to face harsh reality.

While some may take offense to this comparison, the idea of protest as a form of theater remains relevant today. When reality strikes, the consequences can be tragic.