Who Was the Best Boys Lacrosse Player in Section V?

Section V has always been a hotbed for lacrosse talent, and now people are voting on who deserves the title of greatest ever.

The discussion started with a review of All‑American honors, local all‑state picks, and the big moments that defined each player’s career.

Experts and coaches were asked to weigh in, but the answer is far from obvious. The game has changed so much that comparing players from different eras feels like comparing apples to oranges.

From the 1960s to today, a handful of names keep popping up:

• Terry Corcoran – His family helped shape New York lacrosse, and he himself won two Division III national titles with Hobart.
• Dan Groot – Dominated his team in the 2000s and earned national recognition.
• Jack Hinderland – A powerhouse in the 2000s who also gained national acclaim.
• Ben Reeves – Still holds the record for most points in a single season.
• Blaze Riorden – Captured the nation’s attention with a viral goal‑keeping moment.
• TD Ierlan – A face‑off king whose grabs helped Victor win state titles.
• Tom Rosa – Combined face‑offs with scoring to lead Hobart to multiple championships.
• Guy Van Arsdale – A legendary goalie known for his shot‑blocking skills.

Some players were celebrated for offensive firepower, others for defense or face‑off mastery. Goalies like Guy Van Arsdale and Blaze Riorden have also left indelible marks with their shot‑blocking skills.

The debate continues because every era produced different styles and challenges. Who truly deserves the crown depends on whether you value scoring records, championship wins, or overall impact on the sport.

Fans are invited to share their thoughts and suggest any overlooked legends who might deserve a spot on the list.