Ever wondered who is liable if psychiatrists are unable to prevent their patients from committing suicide?

     Let's examine the diverse laws around the world about a psychiatrist's legal responsibilities regarding suicide. Countries have different approaches to suicide as a crime. Some countries still have penalties for suicide attempts or help in other cases. Suddenly. This discussion becomes even more complex when considering the controversial topic of euthanasia or medically assisted suicide, which is allowed in some places.

         This situation has sparked endless debates on how to care for severe mental illness, particularly when it comes to treating individuals who may attempt to end their lives.

         What does this mean for suicide prevention? Everything. A psychiatrist's job is to care for patients, not monitor them around the clock, 24/7, expecting the unpredictable!

      Psychiatrists face constant debate over involuntary treatment. Involuntary treatment is when a person is required to receive treatment for a mental illness with the law enforcing that person to do so even if that person refuses.

      Suicide is a commonly debated topic around the world,  but it's important to remember that not everyone has the same view on the topic. This can make the situation complicated for some people.  In junior school, if there is a fight and as a teacher you are unable to stop the fight, you can not be blamed for the situation. It's agreed that this is not the same.  This is a completely different situation as the role of psychiatrists differ.

        Imagine what it would be like to lose your job because of a patient who decides to end their life. How fair is it to hold psychiatrists responsible for actions they couldn't always have predicted? Furthermore, the idea that a psychiatrist should be responsible for their patient ending their own life changes with how society sees suicide.  In some places, they want to be a part of it.

        Let's imagine if you were trying to give someone a warning to stop a crime happening and they thought you were being a bit too pushy so they tried to end their life. It could be quite complicated. You might think you were helping but others might think differently. In the future, it will be very difficult to predict what can happen to you as a psychiatrist. Or the patient. Or even what will happen to the psychiatrist's family.

        It's crucial to consider that psychiatrists have a tough job.   Some patients are diagnosed to have conditions that may impact their decision making or rational thinking. For them, asking assistance can be hard.

        Psychiatric patients are often those who's life is turned upside down by suicide.  Their choices, actions, and well-being all boil down to this. Not only are psychiatrists dealing with trying to navigate medical response to severe mental health crisis but they are also dealing with trying to figure out what to do when they feel threatened.

        It's equally important to consider there are ways to prevent suicide attempts by strict supervision.  This would make it easier for a psychiatrist to avoid being sued.

        For example, how useful is it to blame doctors when someone decides to burn a car? Why would you hold a psychiatrist responsible if a patient dies?

     When dealing with lawsuits, there are many different factors to consider. It does make sense that if someone else is hurt by the choices and actions of another, there should be a way to hold the individuals accountable for their actions.

Who's Responsible When the Unthinkable Happens? Psychiatrists and Suicide Liability Worldwide

Actions