Faculty Committee Pushes for Professor’s Return After Controversial Posts
A faculty committee at the University of Arkansas in Fayetteville has issued a unanimous recommendation that Dr. Shirin Saeidi—an Iranian‑born political science professor—should not be terminated. The decision comes after the dean of the Fulbright College announced in December that Dr. Saeidi would be relieved from her role as director of the King Fahd Center for Middle East Studies.
Background
- Suspension: Dr. Saeidi was suspended over her social media activity, which the dean claimed included:
- Criticism of Israel’s military actions in Gaza
- Calls for a free Palestine
- Mentions of Iranian leaders
Use of university letterhead in political statements deemed inappropriate
Appeal Process: The University of Arkansas Faculty Committee on Appointment, Promotion, and Tenure reviews evidence and forwards its recommendation to the university president, who has final authority.
Committee Findings
- The committee’s unanimous stance found no violation of university policy, distinguishing protected speech from conduct that truly breaches rules.
- Dr. Saeidi’s hearing took place on Monday, but the formal recommendation was delivered to the president only on Friday.
Implications for Academic Freedom
- Dr. Saeidi’s attorney views the outcome as a victory for academic freedom and free expression on campus.
- He argues that public universities cannot dismiss tenured faculty solely because their political views are unpopular or controversial.
- The decision is framed as upholding First Amendment principles and protecting professors from political pressure.
Cautionary Context
- A unanimous recommendation does not guarantee job security. The university has previously dismissed faculty after faculty panels advised against it, citing political controversy or social media comments.
- Recent examples include:
- A law school dean whose position was withdrawn after lawmakers discovered her support for transgender athletes.
- A professor fired despite a faculty panel recommending against termination.
Current Developments
- Dr. Saeidi posted the dean’s letter on Instagram, asserting that her speech is protected.
- Her lawyer alleges political motivation behind the dismissal, citing pressure from groups critical of her views on Iran and Israel.
- The Middle East Studies Association has called for her reinstatement.
- Some state senators have publicly supported the university’s investigation into her conduct.
Broader Tension
The case highlights a tension between academic freedom and institutional control, raising questions about how universities balance faculty expression with their public image—especially when political issues are involved. Whether Dr. Saeidi will ultimately return to teaching and research remains uncertain, but the faculty committee’s decision marks a notable stand in favor of protecting scholarly voices.
